With 354 pieces, the LEGO Big Bad Island (71412) is a compact build that doesn't waste a piece. It launched in 2022 under the Super Mario banner at $44.99. You get 4 minifigures in the box, which adds to the collectible appeal.
At $0.127 per piece, it runs a bit higher — but that often reflects larger or more specialized elements.
Licensed Super Mario sets like this tend to attract both LEGO fans and franchise enthusiasts, which keeps demand high even after retirement.
Key Features
354 pieces — Compact and purpose-built — great for a quick session
4 minifigures — Adds play value and aftermarket appeal
$0.127 per piece — Strong price-per-piece for this theme
Expansion Set collection — Sought-after corner of the Super Mario lineup
Released 2022 — Super Mario sets from this period are known for their build quality
Theme Background
The Big Bad Island falls under the LEGO Super Mario theme, sitting in the Expansion Set subtheme — a dedicated part of the LEGO catalog. Launched in 2022 at $44.99, it sits in the accessible end of Super Mario. The $0.127 per piece is in line with Super Mario averages.
The Expansion Set subcategory within Super Mario has its own collector base, and sets in this range tend to hold interest well after retirement. Worth keeping on the radar if you're building a Super Mario collection.
Why This Set Is Special
Strong appreciation at +60%. Market value of $71.99 represents a 60% premium over its $44.99 retail price.
Strong part-out value at 1.6x — Parts are worth $70.91 vs $44.99 retail (1.6x ratio). Theme average is 2.5x.
Frequently Asked Questions
[{"q": "How many pieces are in the LEGO Big Bad Island (71412)?", "a": "The LEGO Big Bad Island (71412) contains 354 pieces, making it a smaller set."}, {"q": "What minifigures come with the LEGO Big Bad Island (71412)?", "a": "The LEGO Big Bad Island (71412) includes a solid complement of 4 minifigures. Minifigures are a key value driver for LEGO sets \u2014 exclusive or rare minifigures can appreciate significantly in value on their own, sometimes commanding high prices on the secondary market."}, {"q": "How much does the LEGO Big Bad Island (71412) cost?", "a": "The retail price (MSRP) for the LEGO Big Bad Island (71412) is $44.99 in the United States. Regional pricing is \u00a339.99 in the UK, CA$59.99 in Canada, \u20ac44.99 in Europe. This works out to $0.13 per piece. While you get fewer pieces per dollar than some other Super Mario sets, the build quality and specialized elements justify the premium."}, {"q": "Is the LEGO Big Bad Island (71412) a good investment?", "a": "The LEGO Big Bad Island (71412) shows moderate investment potential based on several factors. Super Mario sets have historically been among the best-performing themes for post-retirement appreciation. As with any LEGO investment, buying at or below retail price maximizes potential returns. Use the BrickBucks price tracker to find the best entry point."}, {"q": "What age is the LEGO Big Bad Island (71412) suitable for?", "a": "The LEGO Big Bad Island (71412) is recommended for ages 7+. The build is designed to be approachable for younger builders while still providing an enjoyable experience."}, {"q": "How big is the LEGO Big Bad Island (71412)?", "a": "The LEGO Big Bad Island (71412) measures approximately 35.4cm \u00d7 19.1cm \u00d7 9.1cm (W\u00d7H\u00d7D). It makes for a great display piece that won't take up too much shelf space."}, {"q": "Is the LEGO Big Bad Island (71412) still available?", "a": "The LEGO Big Bad Island (71412) retired on July 31, 2023 and is no longer available at retail. You can find this set on secondary markets including Amazon, eBay, and BrickLink. Retired Super Mario sets often trade at a premium above their original retail price, with demand typically increasing over time as sealed inventory decreases."}, {"q": "Where can I buy the LEGO Big Bad Island (71412)?", "a": "The LEGO Big Bad Island (71412) is retired and only available on secondary markets. Check Amazon, eBay, and BrickLink for current listings. Use the BrickBucks price tracker to compare prices across retailers and find the best deal."}]
